[PC-NCSG] Fwd: FW: NCSG Meeting with the Board : Topics (Constituency Day)

[avri doria]

On 23-Oct-16 17:15, Edward Morris wrote:
> ,/or could, be prohibited/.
>  
> That's the hard part.
>  
> It could be prohibited by contract should the ICANN community wish.
> Given the makeup of the community, I'm not sure that is realistic. At
> the best, perhaps we could get certain guarantees of due process for
> registrants  built into contracts.

Well, all you need to do is build consensus in the New gTLD Subsequent
Procedures PDP WG that these should not be allowed.  In that process, I
would be a neutral co-chair.  Of course that would mean sending in
comments when we get to that part (WT2 I believe) and participating in
the subgroup.  Making it retroactive would require further effort.

I tend to be less concerned than McKinnon or the EFF as long as there is
wide choice of provider.  In the case of [mon, Duo]opoly, e.g. if .com
and .biz was all we had, then I would feel similarly.  BTW  I read the
service agrements, I think everyone should and I see no reason to assume
people do not need to.  But I would go beyond that.  ICANN has required
that certain conditions be made clear and that users be notified of
certain condition in, so to speak, large type and frequently.

avri

PS. and thee is nothing better than a Crispy Creme.  Just have to make
sure that the diet is varied and donuts are not the only thing there is
to consume.

> Thanks for letting us know, Avri.

It is in my SOI, but I figured I would mention it since we frequently
have problems in NCSG of people not telling who their contracts are
with.  And since I was making a comment on something that regards them,
wanted to make sure it was clearly known.

>  
> It saddens me a bit because

Got to make a living.  But it is one reason I frequently bring up te
issue of members who have contracts with commercial outfits.  Don't want
it to spring up as a surprise someday when someone want to nail me for
something or other.

cheers
avri





---
This email has been checked for viruses by Avast antivirus software.
https://www.avast.com/antivirus